AZ Business Leader Opposes Immigration Referral: A Economic Analysis of the Protecting Arizona Against Illegal Immigration Act

On May 8, 2024, Lorena Van Assche, a board member of the Arizona Hispanic Chamber of Commerce, spoke out against the Protecting Arizona Against Illegal Immigration Act during a press conference. She argued that the act would not make economic sense for the state and could lead to costly litigation if implemented. Van Assche also referenced the negative impact that past immigration legislation, such as SB 1070, had on the state’s economy.

Van Assche highlighted that E-verify is already a requirement by law in Arizona and that the state has strong legal statutes in place to address fraudulent behavior related to immigration. The proposed referral would expand the E-verify requirement to include industries that were previously exempt, such as construction, agriculture, and hospitality. It would also increase legal penalties for employers who do not comply.

The proposal is similar to a bill that was previously vetoed by Governor Katie Hobbs. If approved, the proposal would be presented to voters during the November general elections, bypassing the governor’s veto authority. The Arizona Hispanic Chamber of Commerce opposes the act based on its potential negative economic impact on the state and the existing legal framework already in place to address immigration issues.